Your help has seriously been invaluable, thank you for investing so much time to help a stranger.

Think I got everything resolved! Decided I'd just forego the whole "second router" problem and connected to the router thats connected to our modem. Forwarded the ports on THAT router and got an all clear on my ports from canyouseeme.org

Pretty sure it was a port problem from using multiple routers in the same house. Haven't been able to test it from a source outside my network yet, but can PM you my external IP with a username/password for the server if you feel like being awesome and testing it for me! :D

I didn't know you were behind two routers... :oops:

Anyways, I'm glad you got it working, and I'm only happy to help.


Sure thing.