When I still played on Live, the Warrior guru in the guild I was in had a huge write up posted (prolly from Steelwarriors) about how melee dmg was calculated. It's based on STR, weapon dmg, weapon skill primarily (iirc) and in some cases hidden mods (SK's hitting harder with certain weapons than a pally).
I don't know how try that last bit it is as I've never gotten into it enough to parse it.
In short I would try what fourier suggested... but maybe on a couple select weapons as a test. Then try his suggested query if it checks out.
|