[Shingen]

Realistically, he's providing INFORMATION on the emulators.

It's not unlike a "Windows For Dummies" guide.

However, the other side of the issue is this: It's hard to keep a guide going where you stay on top of every development of an open source project like this one.

It's different for things like PHP or SQL where there are definitive "milestone" releases - EQEmu is updated all the time with no real milestone releases.

So the worst you can probably say 'bout this guy is that he may be misleading people somewhat with old information. If he was selling a CD with EQEmu on it, that'd be different.