Please rate this

I'm trying to make banners and gif animations and things of that sort but im really not sure if im good or bad at it. I just want peoples comments. And, throw my history away when u rate this cause I know people hate me. But just rate this on what u think. (Pretend I didnt make it )

[Trumpcard]

A+ !

Looks great !

ok heres another one I know it somewhat looks like a POS but at least its a start... and rate it as you did the other banner.

[outerlimit]

The first one is okay, but the edges on some of the letterings seem to have...I dunno how to describe, crusty? Maybe applying a light blur to it would make it look a bit smoother.

The GIF...I think there's too many lighting effects on the Jedi Knight 3 letterings, and the other words aren't quite delayed enough. Like for "Rebels Of Another Realm," try to make it so those frames last longer, so there effect sets in more.

Hope that helps.

[JohnRev]

Looks pretty good.

[shm4nt3r]

meh... 5/10 (not that I could do better, but anyways)